May 20, 2014; St. Petersburg, FL, USA; Oakland Athletics second baseman Eric Sogard (28) works out prior to the game against the Tampa Bay Rays at Tropicana Field. Mandatory Credit: Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports

The Eric Sogard Conundrum

Use your ← → (arrows) to browse

Rest assured, I hold no ill-will toward Eric Sogard.

For all intents and purposes he appears to be an outstanding human being – amicable to fans and great embracer of the “Nerdpower” and #FaceofMLB movements in his honor. I’m sure he also helps little old ladies with their groceries and recycles responsibly too.

Unfortunately, none of his qualities of virtue represent a solid professional baseball player. As entertaining as it is to craft photoshopped versions of his visage to win meaningless contests – they don’t help win games, and they never will. In all reality, Sogard is neither the longterm answer at second base, nor does his meager production warrant much confidence in the present.

He’s simply a platoon stop-gate, overexposed by big league pitching and nearly devoid of any longterm potential. In 127 plate appearances this season the 28-year old has posted a paltry .195/.265/.233 mark, giving fans little opportunity to throw up the specs in any form or fashion. Over the course of his 235 game career, his lifetime .232/.289/.322 mark and 2.3 accumulated WAR place him in line with the likes of Jason Donald and Lou Collier – run of the mill, Quadruple-A players.

In fact his value at the Major League level lies not within the marketability of his bespectacled effigy, but his defensive abilities at the second base position. Even in a time share for the majority of the last two seasons, Sogard – to his credit has provided a positive impact in the field having yet to make an error in 188 chances this season, and finishing fourth amongst American League second basemen with a 4.84 range factor in 2013.

However, essentially lacking a well-rounded game sends him hurtling into a career of baseball anonymity. While murmurs of a second base upgrade via the trade route have begun to emanate from the insiders, no move appears imminent. So for now, enjoy the official team-sanctioned music videos, t-shirts, and nerd memorabilia in his name - because it certainly won’t last forever.



Use your ← → (arrows) to browse
Next Athletics Game View full schedule »
Wednesday, Sep 33 Sep12:35Seattle MarinersBuy Tickets

Tags: Eric Sogard Oakland Athletics

  • Jordan Hiser

    Awesome piece! I need to bring this kind of breakdown to the Reds in Cincinnati on Riverfront Ball. This is fantastic.

    • Devin Pangaro

      Thanks Jordan, sincerely appreciated.

  • Tony Frye

    That is so true. If he could hit around .240 consistently, he’d be a huge asset to the team with average hitting and excellent fielding. I love the guy but it is hard to see him slumping so bad right now.

    With all the platooning at second base (don’t we have about 18 players sharing the position) is it possible that under-exposure at the plate is hurting him? Maybe more at bats would get him out of the slump and hitting around his career average again.

    For all the good the A’s have pulled out of platooning, I think it really hurts guys when they struggle a bit.