Josh Donaldson, Ed Szczepanski-USA TODAY Sports

Athletics and Giants: Entering June #1 and #2


When we first started this string of pieces comparing the two teams, it was no contest. The Athletics and Giants were coming off years that were polar opposites. As the calendar flips to June, the Athletics and Giants are the top two teams in MLB. Yes, the Giants have the better record at 36-20, but our Oakland Athletics (34-22) are still the better team.

Many Giants fans will say that the Houston Astros (24-33) pad the A’s record. This is technically true, because the A’s are 5-2 against Houston this season, but they have a better record than the Arizona Diamondbacks (23-35), whom the Giants are 4-3 against. That’s just nitpicking though. Let’s dig deeper.

The Giants did have to deal with the injury to Brandon Belt this month, and have compensated for his absence nicely. Pablo Sandoval was as productive in the first month as Kendrys Morales. In May Sandoval decided to play like he actually wants a contract next season and has been making up for lost time. Kudos.

The A’s lost 2 members of their rotation before the season started, have been having problems closing out games and weren’t getting production from the bottom of their rotation for a month. Somehow they’re still only 2 games behind the Giants for the best record in MLB. I score that one for the Athletics.

Before you say, “But Matt Cain hasn’t been pitching either…” stop. Cain hasn’t brought a plethora of wins to the table, neigh he’s responsible for one. “The Horse” has barely gotten out of the stable.

The A’s pitching has been fantastic this season, leading the Giants in ERA (2.93), Shut Outs (7), Quality Starts (34), Earned Runs (163), Runs (175) and BAA (.221).

Couple this staff with the bats in the A’s lineup, and you get one lopsided run differential, currently at +112. Brandon Moss has become a feared hitter in 2014, batting .276, with 13 HRs and 46 RBIs. Yoenis Cespedes is feared both at the plate and in left field. Not Michael Morse and his -0.9 dWAR–when can we sub him out kind of fear– but throwing out two runners at home in one inning kind of feared.

Then there’s  Josh Donaldson. He is currently tied with Troy Tulowitzki for best all-around player in baseball this season with a 4.6 overall WAR. Last season was no fluke, folks. Which one of our 3rd basemen should be asking for the big contract? Not the chubby one.

Brandon Hicks has found “new life” across the Bay with the Giants. He is beloved by the fans for his 8 HRs, 20 RBI and .181 BA. Believe it or not, the .181 he is hitting now has actually raised his career average. That production should totally last.

Want more from Swingin' A's?  
Subscribe to FanSided Daily for your morning fix.
Enter your email and stay in the know.

I will give the Giants’ bullpen credit. They have a 2.53 ERA as a group, and Jean Machi leads the way with 27 IP and a 0.33 ERA himself. Again, Kudos.

For all of their issues, the A’s bullpen still has just a 2.82 ERA. The problem for them has been the timing of those runs. The assumption is that this will be worked out when Ryan Cook and Eric O’Flaherty join the ‘pen in June. Everyone will return to a spot they’re more comfortable in, and Jim Johnson can just sit there. Problem solved.

The month of June for the Athletics and Giants will be interesting. The A’s upcoming schedule will involve facing seemingly every team that hopes to make the playoffs in 2014, while the Giants don’t really have any tests on the schedule. That is, until July when the Athletics and Giants play a four-game set for bragging rights. The games count in the standings too, but for the fans it’s all about bragging rights.




Next Athletics Game View full schedule »
Tuesday, Sep 22 Sep7:05Seattle MarinersBuy Tickets

Tags: Oakland Athletics San Francisco Giants

  • whitmanguy

    In the end it is W-L that determines which team is the best, not run production.

    The comments on Cain here are pretty disingenuous. He has had two stints on the DL, which means not only that his services were unavailable during them, but that his form has been adversely affected. And the Giants have lost the hard hitting and good fielding Brandon Belt for 6 weeks. It is a team with depth that may prove invaluable as the season wears on, as no team gets to October without some injuries.

    By the end of the season it may well be that the A’s have proven themselves to be the better team. Quite possible. But right now it is the Giants, according to the only stat that counts.

    • Jason Burke

      I will say this, the Giants can’t seem to lose the last couple of weeks. They’re playing very good baseball. My biased take is that the A’s could still take them though. I’m looking forward to the series in July. Hopefully both teams are fully healthy when it occurs.

      • whitmanguy

        As I said, I’m not denying that the A’s may do that, and finish with a better record; they are very, very good.

        As a Giant fan I had looked forward to an improvement on last year, but nothing like this. So I’m not confident that they will continue as at present, though hopeful that they will play above .500 ball for the rest of the season, as that should see them into the playoffs. But they do have an interesting team. I don’t know if you’ve been paying close attention, but their current record has been compiled despite woeful slumps from two of their top hitters, Sandoval and Pence, for the first few weeks of the season, as well as the loss of Belt. They just seem to be able to pick up the slack when necessary, and fill holes. Very interesting that not one position player will be an All Star starter, yet the team is at the moment the winningest in baseball. Power and clutch hitting–they lead the league in 2out RBIs–throughout the lineup makes them tough to beat.

        Yes, I’m looking forward to the Bay series too. Should be fun. Not looking forward, though, to this week’s series in Cincy. The Giants haven’t performed well there in recent years (except in the 2012 playoffs), and they have to open with their two weakest starters.

        • Jason Burke

          I also write for Golden Gate Sports, and mainly talk about the Giants on that page. I don’t get to catch all of their games, but living and working in SF gives me a good sense of how the team is going. I interact with the public a lot at work, and bounce my thoughts of their team off of them. Generally they agree with the assessments.

          For this piece, I obviously added an A’s slant. I’ll be posting a Giants article tomorrow morning for GGS. Check it out!

          Also, thank you for the friendly discussion.

          • whitmanguy

            Thanks, I’ll watch for the article.

            If you are looking for content still, you can borrow my suggestion that the front runner at this point in the race for NL MVP isn’t Tulowitzki or Puig, it’s Brian Sabean.